Forex Analysis & Reviews: GBP/USD. Pound optimism premature: Johnson has to go through 9 circles of "political hell"
time 04.10.2019 08:28 AM
time Rilevanza fino a, 06.10.2019 08:26 AM

Yesterday's surge in volatility for the pound-dollar pair was due not only to the Brexit theme. The US currency continues to demonstrate its vulnerability amid a slowdown in important economic indicators and in anticipation of the release of Nonfarms. This combination of fundamental factors made it possible for GBP/USD bulls to update the weekly high and approach the 24th figure. Nevertheless, the further growth of the pair remains in doubt: if today's data on the US labor market comes out in the "green zone", the dollar will quickly regain its position throughout the market. Moreover, if it is supported by Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell, who will voice his opinion at the close of the US session (18:00 London time). The situation with Brexit is even more complicated. Cautious optimism in this matter can instantly be replaced by habitual pessimism, after which the pound will return to the price range of 1.2000-1.2250. There are certain prerequisites for this.

This image is no longer relevant

By and large, yesterday's optimism of GBP/USD traders was explained by one factor: rumors appeared in the British press that the Conservative Party and their temporary allies from the Democratic Union Party were ready to support Boris Johnson's new Brexit proposals. But it is worth noting here that, firstly, such rumors over the 3.5 years of the epic of the negotiation process have often not been confirmed. Secondly, in Europe they were rather skeptical about the initiatives of the British prime minister. And although the head of the European Commission called the voiced proposals "a breakthrough," many facts suggest otherwise. Almost all experts, politicians and journalists on both sides of the English Channel are confident that Johnson's "new plan" is doomed to failure.

The backstop is the root of the problem. Brexit supporters were initially against the "transparent" border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. Instead of a back-stop indefinite mechanism, Johnson proposed an alternative - a "translucent" border. According to him, customs checks will return to the island - both on land and at sea - but they will be practically invisible to those crossing the border. Nevertheless, the border is de facto returned, and customs posts, even at a remote distance from the borders, remain customs posts, regardless of their location. This proposal does not suit many politicians - both among Europeans and among the British. In particular, the Laborites have already called Johnson's plan "terrifying."

The remaining items are also ambiguous. For example, the British prime minister proposed that the Northern Ireland Assembly (the Parliament of the region) have a veto. Local deputies must confirm the legitimacy of the agreement with the European Union at 4-year intervals; otherwise, Belfast will return to the orbit of British law. This idea was received "with hostility" both in Brussels and in Dublin. In addition, judging by the newspaper headlines in the European press, EU countries also do not support such an initiative.

Firstly, the aforementioned Assembly has not held its meetings for more than three years (!) Due to the lack of a quorum. Local political confrontations, which are protracted, blocked the work of this body. Secondly, Europeans are indignant at the very formulation of the question: in fact, a relatively small region will decide the fate of the European integration processes. And given the background to the relationship between Dublin and Belfast, it is impossible to imagine that the authorities of the Republic of Ireland agreed on such a mechanism. President of the European Council Donald Tusk has already managed to declare that in this matter he fully supports Varadkar, and the proposals of the British prime minister are "unconvincing" for him.

This image is no longer relevant

Another obstacle to agreeing on the "Johnson Plan" is purely technical in nature. Not only political will is needed to implement his proposals in European law. The legal approval process involves the consent of all 27 member countries of the European Union. According to the participants in previous negotiations (when Theresa May was in office), this is quite a time-consuming process. All of them unanimously argue that the parties will not have time to prepare the relevant document before the EU summit, which will take place in just two weeks.

Thus, Johnson has to solve a number of difficult tasks. First of all, he needs to convince the EU leadership, as well as representatives of the EU member countries of the need to agree on the above changes. Then the negotiating group needs in a short time - about two weeks - to prepare a legally verified document, which should be supported at the EU summit. If the British prime minister passes all these millstones, then only on October 19-20 will he bring an updated draft of the deal to London, which will need to be agreed with the deputies of the House of Commons. Here it is worth recalling that as a result of recent "purges", the Conservatives expelled more than 20 from their ranks. Therefore, Johnson will need to seek support "on the side", that is, among other deputy groups. The Labour Party has already categorically disagreed with his plan, while the positions of the other parties (except for the DUP and the representatives of Scotland) are still unknown.

In other words, the position of the British currency is currently quite precarious. Rumors of support for Conservatives and DUP provided temporary support to the pound, but long positions on the GBP/USD pair look risky: there are too many "ifs" in the way of Boris Johnson. Therefore, based on the results of Nonfarm and Jerome Powell's speech, one can consider short positions with the downward targets of 1.2270 and 1.2180 (the Kijun-sen line and the lower border of the Kumo cloud on D1, respectively). It's too early to speak about deeper kickbacks - the stages of the negotiation process over the next two weeks will "throw" the pair from side to side until the prospects of Brexit are finally determined.

Irina Manzenko,
Esperto analista di InstaForex
© 2007-2022
Approfittati subito dei consigli degli analisti
Deposita i fondi sul conto di trading
Apri un conto di trading

Le recensioni analitiche di InstaForex ti renderanno pienamente consapevole delle tendenze del mercato! Essendo un cliente InstaForex, ti viene fornito un gran numero di servizi gratuiti per il trading efficiente.

  • Trade Wise, Win Device
    Top up your account with at least $500, sign up for the contest, and get a chance to win mobile devices.
  • Ferrari from InstaForex
    Top up your account with at least $1,000
    join the contest and win Ferrari
    F8 Tributo
  • Chancy Deposit
    Deposit your account with $3,000 and win $1,000
  • 100% Bonus
    Your unique opportunity to get a 100% bonus on your deposit
  • 55% Bonus
    Apply for a 55% bonus on your every deposit
  • 30% Bonus
    Receive a 30% bonus every time you top up your account

Recommended Stories

Il presidente della Fed ha preannunciato il crollo del dollaro statunitense

L'euro e la sterlina britannica con molta probabilità continueranno a salire dopo che il presidente Jerome Powell ha lasciato intendere ieri che la Federal Reserve avrebbe rallentato l'aumento dei tassi

Jakub Novak 16:52 2022-12-02 UTC+2

I timori di una recessione aumentano il prezzo dell'oro

Secondo l'ultimo rapporto dell'Institute of Supply Management (ISM), il mercato dell'oro si mantiene sopra la soglia di 1.800 dollari l'oncia, dato che aumentano i timori di una recessione

Irina Yanina 14:57 2022-12-02 UTC+2

EUR/USD. Attenzione ai libri paga non agricoli (Nonfarm Payrolls)

Il focus è su Nonfarm Payrolls. Se essi deludono i tori del dollaro (oltre al PCE e all'indice manifatturiero ISM), il biglietto verde subirà ulteriori pressioni in tutto il mercato

Irina Manzenko 09:53 2022-12-02 UTC+2

L'Europa non morirà di freddo: il denaro scorre come un fiume

Stando all'ultimo report, l'Europa ha contribuito enormemente per assicurare l'approvvigionamento energetico e la protezione dei consumatori dagli sbalzi. Solo questo mese l'UE ha speso più di 700 miliardi di euro

Jakub Novak 08:36 2022-11-30 UTC+2

Verbale della Fed: il tasso aumenterà, ma più lentamente e possibilmente più a lungo.

Mercoledì è stato il giorno più interessante di questa settimana. Oltre a una serie piuttosto ampia di dati statistici provenienti da Regno Unito, Stati Uniti e UE, abbiamo anche conosciuto

Chin Zhao 06:30 2022-11-25 UTC+2

La Banca d'Inghilterra potrebbe anche tagliare i tassi di interesse nel prossimo futuro.

La Banca d'Inghilterra è ora un "cavallo oscuro". Nonostante il regolatore britannico abbia alzato il suo tasso più a lungo della Fed e della BCE (ma più lentamente), è difficile

Chin Zhao 06:30 2022-11-25 UTC+2

Non tutti i funzionari della Fed vedono la politica futura allo stesso modo

L'euro è riuscito a tornare su un livello piuttosto importante intorno a 1,0335, il che ci consente di contare sul proseguimento del trend rialzista, soprattutto in un contesto di aumento

Jakub Novak 09:02 2022-11-23 UTC+2

La pubblicazione dei verbali della Fed provocherà forti movimenti sui mercati? (prevediamo che la coppia GBPUSD si consolidi e l'EURUSD cresca prima della pubblicazione del verbale della Fed)

Il mercato continua ad essere "noioso" senza un trend stabile definito in attesa della pubblicazione dei verbali dell'ultimo incontro della Fed sulla politica monetaria di oggi e della festa nazionale

Pati Gani 09:02 2022-11-23 UTC+2

La Banca centrale della Nuova Zelanda potrebbe aumentare i tassi immediatamente di 75 punti base

Il dollaro neozelandese ha reagito con sufficiente calma alla notizia che la Banca centrale della Nuova Zelanda è pronta ad aumentare i tassi di interesse di 75 punti base senza

Jakub Novak 08:41 2022-11-22 UTC+2

Previsioni di Metals Focus per il 2023

Oro e argento hanno mostrato un forte aumento nel mese di novembre, ma i metalli preziosi devono ancora affrontare difficoltà nel 2023 poiché la politica monetaria degli Stati Uniti

Irina Yanina 11:51 2022-11-18 UTC+2
In questo momento non potete parlare al telefono?
Ponete la vostra domanda nella chat.