Forex Analysis & Reviews: The Fed's minutes: split opinions, QE-4 issue and risks of US-China conflict
time 10.10.2019 06:12 AM
time Relevance up to, 11.10.2019 06:09 AM

The minutes of the Federal Reserve are relatively rare to provoke strong volatility among dollar pairs. As a rule, after a two-week period after the last meeting, the market is already aware of the general mood of the regulator, thanks to the speeches of many of them. Yesterday, the Fed minutes was no exception in this regard: its key points were not a revelation for traders, so the dollar reacted minimally to this release. In addition, market participants are waiting for other, more important and relevant events of a fundamental nature - first of all, we are talking about trade negotiations between the United States and China, as well as data on the growth of US inflation, which will be published today.

Nevertheless, it is not worth completely ignoring the "minutes". And although this document did not affect the dynamics of the dollar in the moment "here and now", its value should not be underestimated. For example, yesterday's release once again reminded the market that the Fed had a serious split of opinions, and this fact may affect further decisions of the US regulator.

This image is no longer relevant

Let me remind you that at the September meeting, the Federal Reserve lowered the interest rate by 25 basis points. Against this step were such members of the Fed as the head of the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas, Esther George and the head of the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, Eric Rosengren. They were against easing the monetary policy in July, so the last meeting only confirmed their position. Moreover, the dot plot of the Fed members' expectations (dot plot) suggests that George and Rosengren are not united in their opinion. So, seven officials of the Federal Reserve stated the appropriateness of further steps to mitigate monetary policy, while five of their colleagues spoke in favor of maintaining a wait-and-see attitude - at least until the end of the year. Another five Fed members did not rule out a 25-point rate increase.

As you can see, the opinions of the Committee members diverged significantly: each has its own arguments in favor of a particular decision. So, according to the doves, the Federal Reserve needs to play ahead of schedule - according to them, lowering the interest rate will help offset the negative consequences of a slowdown in the global economy. In addition, the trade conflict with China has a negative impact on the prospects for US economic development. Supporters of soft monetary policy also pointed to a weak inflation rate, the base indicator of which has not been able to reach the target two percent level for a long time. According to the hawks, the regulator in this case is ahead of the events, depriving itself of the corresponding leverage that will be needed in the future. They believe that the most severe economic upheaval (possibly) is yet to come, so the regulator needs to pause now or even increase the rate by 25 points.

Despite the existing split in the Fed camp, the market is almost certain that the regulator will resort to another round of rate reduction: the probability of this step is almost 90%. Many of them do not exclude a double decline in November and December. In my opinion, such a scenario will be implemented in the event of the failure of the US-China negotiations and a new round of trade war. It is necessary to note one more important thesis of the published minutes: members of the Federal Reserve agreed that they would make decisions on rates, focusing on economic data. It is worth recalling that in recent years, US releases have not pleased dollar bulls: the producer price index and the ISM production index came out in the red zone, slowing down and not significantly reaching forecast values. If today's data on inflation in the US will also disappoint, then the likelihood of at least one rate cut will increase to 100%.

Another important nuance. During his last speech, the head of the Fed unexpectedly announced that soon the US central bank will resume regular operations on the open market, increasing its balance sheet account. The market interpreted this step in its own way - according to a number of experts, the regulator, in fact, starts QE-4, although Powell emphasized separately that this is not about the resumption of the stimulating program. According to the minutes of the September meeting, members of the regulator discussed this issue. The head of the Fed said that a series of "spot money injections" to maintain an adequate level of reserves is different from a full-scale quantitative easing program, and markets should understand and accept this difference.

This image is no longer relevant

Thus, the essence of the published minutes is as follows: The Federal Reserve is ready to lower the interest rate further. Another question is when exactly this must be done: before or after possible economic shocks. Some advocate the use of preventive measures, while others urge not to spend leverage that may come in handy in the future.

All this suggests that the fate of the interest rate again depends on the outcome of trade negotiations between Washington and Beijing. If they fail, the rate will probably be reduced at the next meeting. Otherwise, the regulator may take a wait-and-see attitude until the beginning of next year, tracking the dynamics of key US macroeconomic indicators.

Irina Manzenko,
Analytical expert of InstaForex
© 2007-2022
Benefit from analysts’ recommendations right now
Top up trading account
Open trading account

InstaForex analytical reviews will make you fully aware of market trends! Being an InstaForex client, you are provided with a large number of free services for efficient trading.

  • Trade Wise, Win Device
    Top up your account with at least $500, sign up for the contest, and get a chance to win mobile devices.
  • Ferrari from InstaForex
    Top up your account with at least $1,000
    join the contest and win Ferrari
    F8 Tributo
  • Chancy Deposit
    Deposit your account with $3,000 and win $1,000
  • 100% Bonus
    Your unique opportunity to get a 100% bonus on your deposit
  • 55% Bonus
    Apply for a 55% bonus on your every deposit
  • 30% Bonus
    Receive a 30% bonus every time you top up your account

Recommended Stories

Euro: Business as usual, time for fun

Thanksgiving day, the closing of the U.S. stock markets and the outflow of liquidity caused the EUR/USD pair to get bored at the end of the last full week

Marek Petkovich 13:58 2022-11-26 UTC+2

AUD/NZD. Marathon: Kiwi starts and wins

This week, the New Zealand dollar received substantial support from the Reserve Bank of New Zealand: the central bank fully justified the hawkish hopes of most experts by raising

Irina Manzenko 13:54 2022-11-26 UTC+2

EUR/USD. Stubborn 4th figure: Bulls have reached the limit of their capabilities

Bulls on the EUR/USD pair are desperately trying to rise above the 1.0400 level: they repeatedly tried to attack the 4th figure in November, but failed each time. Traders fail

Irina Manzenko 13:43 2022-11-26 UTC+2

Weekly review of GBP/USD for November 21-25, 2022

All elements being clearly bullish, it would be possible for traders to trade only long positions on the GBP/USD pair as long as the price remains well above the golden

Mourad El Keddani 13:42 2022-11-26 UTC+2

Oil ended the week in the red, and the EU countries are in disagreement

Even though this week ended in the red, oil prices rose steadily during Friday trading. The market is still being affected by traders' concerns about China's potential oil demand

Natalia Andreeva 09:21 2022-11-26 UTC+2

GBP/USD. Analysis for the trading week of November 21-25. COT report. The decision of the British Supreme Court supported the pound.

During the most recent week, the GBP/USD currency pair has risen by an additional 200 points. This means that the upward trend is still going strong, and the pound

Paolo Greco 08:54 2022-11-26 UTC+2

EUR/USD. Analysis for the trading week of November 21-25. COT report. The euro currency is once again supported by the market.

This week, the EUR/USD currency pair has again been trading higher. This week, the macroeconomic and fundamental background was nonexistent, but traders still bought euros. Similar trends have been observed

Paolo Greco 08:54 2022-11-26 UTC+2

Ethereum confirms its breakout

ETH/USD retreated a little in the short term after its strong rally. The retreat was natural and now it has developed a bullish pattern. It was trading at 1,185

Ralph Shedler 18:48 2022-11-25 UTC+2

USD/CHF in range pattern, 0.9393 as downside obstacle

The currency pair is moving sideways in the short term. It was trading at 0.9457 at the time of writing. It's trapped between 0.9383 (downside obstacle) and 0.9599 (upside obstacle)

Ralph Shedler 18:47 2022-11-25 UTC+2

Bitcoin continues to trade sideways in a new trading range.

After the FTX scandal and the sell off towards $15,500, Bitcoin has found some balance and is mostly moving sideways. The bulls are absent and there is not enough strength

Alexandros Yfantis 17:57 2022-11-25 UTC+2
Can't speak right now?
Ask your question in the chat.